michael was incredibly helpful and attentive guiding me through the engagement ring buying process. my fiance was LOVED the diamond and ring. highly recommend mcgivern diamonds.
Review by Jcc4 months ago
While it’s surely a very small thing to anyone else, the rings Mike made for my sons hold incredible meaning in my family. The ring is gold with a lapis stone with a family crest from Scotland carved into it. It is incredibly detailed and should be intricate enough that you can use it to seal wax. It does. The tradition goes back generations for us. Every one of us receives it when we graduate high school or turn 18. I had a moment last night when both boys were home and wearing their rings and I actually choked up. It means they’re grown and heading to chart their own course. For a dad who is struggling a bit with that transition, the symbol of connection amidst transition that the rings represent meant a lot. Thanks for making that possible for us.
Review by Andreniqua4 months ago
Amazing company to do business with. Everything went very smoothly. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for jewlery at a great price with excellent customer service.
Review by Bafford Sbragia5 months ago
Excellent customer service! I had a very specific vision in mind, and Mike McGivern exceeded my expectations!
Review by HarviK6 months ago
Bought engagement ring from mike several years ago and just purchased a band to match . Great experience both times . Service And prices are great!
Review by Børge7 months ago
Very upfront and honest business people. Could not be happier about the whole experience--service, price, selection everything
Review by Heru9 months ago
I give McGivern's my highest recommendation! I am originally from Toledo, but have since moved out of the area, and still there was no where else that I considered to have a custom engagement ring and wedding bands made. Mike McGivern is a pleasure to work with, and makes the entire process so easy. His quick responses throughout the design and ordering processes were very appreciated.
Review by RichDevil9 months ago
It was great doing business with Michael. He provided quick service and would definitely do business with him again!!
Review by Willie TazMan10 months ago
The best place to buy a diamond! The customer service is second to none!
Review by Nguyet11 months ago
We did lots of research before deciding on a jeweler to purchase my engagement ring from. We stumbled upon Overnight Diamonds and what a "gem" we found. Although we are in California and Mike is in Ohio, the experience was so personal and thoughtful.
Mike custom made my ring setting (Edwardian Style). When we received the setting it was just beautiful and I was so happy with the results. Next big step was purchasing the diamond for the setting. Again the service was very personal and timely.
I'm now wearing my new ring and couldn't be happier. It is just beautiful and one-of-a-kind.
Thank you Mike for providing exceptional customer service and for providing me with the ring of my dreams.
Review by Linonbeach Walterick1 year ago
My experience with McGivern Diamonds was stellar from start to finish!
Review by Christianus Cretan1 year ago
Exceptional service in every way possible! I have been working with McGivern Diamonds over the past weeks in order to purchase an engagement ring. Michael quickly responded to all of my emails and provided expert advice on every question I posed. He was tremendously helpful and extremely polite during the entire process. When the ring was initially delivered and did not turn out exactly how I had envisioned, he went above and beyond to correct all of the concerns I had to ensure the ring was perfect. I could not imagine going anywhere else to purchase jewelry and would recommend McGivern Diamonds to all of my family and friends.
Review by Yefreed1 year ago
Bought multiple pieces from Mike through the years. His advice is always straight forward and truthful. Give him rough parameters of what you are looking for and your budget and watch him wow you!
Review by Växthusägare1 year ago
My experience with McGivern Diamonds was stellar from start to finish! I am not new to the Jewelry Industry, in fact quite the opposite. I can say with 100% certainty that Mike McGivern is highly accomplished in his trade and enjoyable to work with.
Review by Daveypez1 year ago
My wife is simply ecstatic about her new ring, and we are both extremely pleased with the entire buying process. Mike is an expert in this field, and his personal touch made the experience even better! We are very satisfied and would recommend McGivern Jewelers to everyone!
Review by Satpal Larrisa1 year ago
Michael of McGivern Diamonds was extremely easy to work with. He enhanced my knowledge of the diamond buying process when I was looking for a engagement ring for my fiancée. I provided him with criteria I was looking for and he gave me even better suggestions. It all led to a perfect ring within my budget. The process was seamless fast and I had the ring in less than a week.
Review by Charmee1 year ago
Extremely easy to work with, very professional and quality product! Would work with Mike again.
Review by Kike1 year ago
got one ring as a gift from my sister.... I simply loved it...
Review by Christyne1 year ago
We have had multiple interactions with McGivern Diamonds over the years, including commissioning custom jewelry and most recently, reconditioning / repair on a couple pieces. Mike is beyond responsive, and their work is beautiful. You can't go wrong with McGivern Diamonds.
Review by Vlogger Zindros1 year ago
Words can't describe how patient and professional Mike and his staff were. As a first time buyer of an engagement set, I was nervous with the whole process of buying an engagement ring. Mike worked with me directly to build and create a perfect wedding set that I'm beyond thrilled to give to my future fiance. Any question I had on pricing, style recommendation, etc. he was able to answer very quickly. I HIGHLY recommend McGivern Diamonds to anyone looking for fantastic service at an affordable price!
Review by Mioshi1 year ago
McGivern Diamonds was highly recommended to me by a friend in graduate school when I was looking for an engagement setting and stone. Could not have been happier with the service, quality, and communication. Shopping for something so important online without going to a brick and mortar is a bit scary but Michael McGivern helped me every step of the way. He custom designed a setting I saw in a jewelry store and liked, however, he did this by only seeing pictures! I'm a picky shopper and went through many different stones before deciding on one. I felt the service and communication far exceeded anything I've found in a local jewelry store. Highly recommend!!!
Review by Rafn1 year ago
Mike McGivern was great to work with. I needed a custom engagement ring that represented a sizeable investment. After piecing together different pictures of rings we saw online, I met with Mike to come up with design and choose the diamonds. She wanted a three stone Emerald Cut Ring with a unique open band. After answering my questions about emerald cut diamonds, I knew I was working with a diamond expert. Although classy and straight-forward this style is a bit unusual these days. Such an important purchase always comes with some level of anxiety That anxiety left me when I saw the CAD design Mike emailed me within a week of the order, I knew the ring design was perfect. The ring arrived a couple weeks later in time to pop the question on her birthday. It was exactly as shown in the CAD diagram. Very classy and the stones were extremely well balanced. The ring was a big success and she can't stop looking at it. Lots of great comments from friends and relatives. To add to the positive customer experience, our appraisal came in thousands over the purchase price. Many thanks to Mike for his help in making this an easy and educational process. I highly recommend McGivern Diamonds.
Review by Freightliner Afanasjevaite1 year ago
Each time we think there's a better store out there, we keep on bouncing back to Michael McGivern. There's no better shop that can live up to their excellent customer service, the prompt response you get, the trust he builds in every transaction, the quality & well priced diamonds, and the treatment a customer deserves no matter what the price of the goods you're purchasing. We've dealt with Mike McGivern over the last 15 years. First, we purchased my engagement ring in 2003 then in 2011, we purchased a pair of almost 1 carat a piece for a pair of earrings and then very recently we had my engagement ring reset to add more stones. Each transaction was a pleasure. No hard selling. I'm loving our latest purchase that adds so much sparkle to my finger. We're sure to return.
Review by Shivanna1 year ago
I've done business with them 3 times over the past 10 years and each time has been remarkable! I live in Hawaii and yet the process has been seamless. Have recommended and will definitely do business again in the future. Thanks Mike!
Review by Célian1 year ago
I got our wedding ring in this company and it puts back memories until now. This company offers high-grade diamonds and a priceless memory for us.
McGivern Diamonds is rated 5.0 based on
Trust Mamma Reviews
Our reviews are aggregated from multiple sources to give you the best overview about overnightdiamonds.com.
McGivern Diamonds is a direct diamond importer. Several times a year we travel overseas, primarily to Tel Aviv, Israel, to buy direct from the cutters. By importing directly, and in large quantities, we are able to buy our diamonds for substantially less, and thus can pass along the savings. We specialize in selling GIA certified diamonds - the industry standard, at direct importer prices. Our online diamond database is one of the largest in the country.
When you deal with us, you are not only dealing with a diamond importer, but a gemologist and manufacturer as well. We have two full time gemologists (GIA) on staff, so you assured of dealing with a knowledgeable staff. We also do complete manufacturing at our Perrysburg location. We make everything from the very simple and traditional, to the very unique "one of a kind" pieces. Our manufacturing facilities gives us a big price advantage as well, as we do not have to buy from some other supplies, we are the supplier! This translates into big savings for you, the customer, as you have all the advantages of buying "factory direct".
Everything we sell is also 100% refundable, satisfaction is guaranteed.
What We Sell
Perhaps it would be easier to list what we do not sell. We do not sell or service watches, sterling silver, or costume jewelry. We offer an extensive line of 10K, 14K, 18K and platinum jewelry. We sell chains, bracelets, and earrings as well as a full line of gemstone jewelry including emerald, ruby, sapphire, amethyst, garnet, topaz, opal and many more. GIA Certified diamonds however, remain our specialty. We have a large selection of loose diamonds from .10 ct. to over 5 cts. We also have many engagement rings and other settings to accommodate these diamonds. Other diamond jewelry we offer includes anniversary rings, tennis bracelets, earrings, pendants, slides and about anything else you can imagine.
112 West Second Street